The encyclopedia · Trading & Investing · Financial decision · 2012–2020
California auctioned carbon permits with a price floor to keep its cap from collapsing
California's 2012 cap-and-trade auction sold allowances at a set minimum and kept a reserve to cap spikes, avoiding the price collapse that gutted EU ETS.
California Air Resources Board
the move
California's cap-and-trade law set a falling cap on greenhouse gases, but a cap only moves behaviour if the resulting allowance price is credible. Europe's first trading phase had collapsed to near zero partly because permits were handed out free and there was no floor.
California's answer was to auction permits and clothe the auction in a price collar. Its first sale, in November 2012, cleared at $10.09 per tonne against a $10 reserve floor, and the program held a reserve of allowance prices in escrow to dampen future spikes.
More than half of allowances go to auction; a share is handed to utilities which must sell them and credit ratepayers, and a reserve fund sits ready to steady prices. The design gives the market a predictable carbon price rather than a gimmicky one.
why it works
- Free allocation gave the EU ETS a price that collapsed to near zero
- A reserve price floor stops a bust before prices lose all meaning
- A containment reserve releases allowances to stop a price spike
- Auctioned revenue returns value to ratepayers and to clean-energy programmes
what transfers
A quantity instrument fails if the price is unstable; putting a floor and a release valve into the same auction gives a cap-and-trade the price certainty that makes it actually reduce emissions.
what came after
California's cap-and-trade became the anchor of a North American carbon market, linking with Quebec and later Ontario. It survived legal challenges and continued through 2030 emissions targets, valued as a workable model for giving a quantity cap a stable price, in contrast to the first EU ETS collapse.
references
- California's first greenhouse gas emissions auction sells near minimum price
- Cap-and-Trade Program: Auction Information
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.