By 1961 professional football's biggest source of revenue was shifting from ticket sales to television, but big-market teams could sell their own local broadcast rights for vastly more than small-market teams could sell theirs, threatening competitive balance across the league. 3 million over two years, individual television stations holding separate deals with individual teams sued, and the same federal judge who had already barred the NFL from restricting where games could be broadcast in a 1953 antitrust case struck the pooled deal down.

A pooled sale looked, to antitrust law written for ordinary product markets, exactly like competitors agreeing to fix a price and divide a market between them — even though a football broadcast doesn't actually compete against other broadcasts of the same game the way two manufacturers compete to sell the same product. Fighting the ruling in court meant relitigating the very 1953 precedent that had just been reaffirmed against the league.

Lobbied Congress for a law exempting only sports leagues' pooled broadcast sales, turning a legal barrier into a legislative fix.

The exemption was scoped to one transaction, so Congress could pass it quickly without broad opposition.

Lawmakers saw a sympathetic reason: small-market teams needed pooled revenue to survive.

The law let the league negotiate as one seller, boosting TV revenue past ticket sales.

When competition law blocks a collective move, seek a narrowly scoped legislative exemption, not broad deregulation.

With the exemption in place, the NFL immediately resold its pooled broadcast rights to CBS, and the deal grew from just over $9 million for two years to more than $28 million on renewal; for the first time, the league's television revenue exceeded its revenue from ticket sales. The same exemption underwrote the broadcast contracts, worth billions of dollars a year decades later, that turned the NFL and other pooled sports leagues into television's most valuable programming.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

The sources

  1. NFL Television Broadcasting Federal Judicial Center · fjc.gov
  2. Throwback Thursday: The TV Deal That Created Modern Sports Vice · vice.com