By 2003 file-sharing had trained music fans to pay nothing for single songs, while record labels kept selling albums at $18 and sued downloaders. The industry treated the single as the enemy of the album. Apple bet the opposite: the unit people actually wanted was the song.

The iTunes Music Store opened April 28, 2003, with 200,000 tracks at 99¢ each, albums at $9.99, tied to iTunes software and the iPod. Apple expected a million songs in the first month; customers bought a million in the first week. Half were bought as part of albums, showing the store even helped albums.

The economics mattered as much as the price: the store cut the transaction cost of buying legal music to near zero, undercut the friction of file-sharing, and gave labels a legal channel. Economists studying digital music documented the underlying shift — unbundling music from the album and pricing it per track.

Unbundle the album; price the song

99¢ matched the value of a single track, not a whole album

A legal store with instant downloads beat the friction of piracy

Single-song sales served the demand file-sharing had revealed

A million first-week sales proved willingness to pay

When a free substitute exists, price against convenience, not against cost: unbundle to the unit consumers actually want and make paying easier than stealing.

iTunes became the largest music retailer in the US within a few years, and the labels that had fought downloads began selling through it. The per-song price became the industry benchmark, and the album's dominance — and its pricing power — never fully recovered.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

The sources

  1. iTunes store: More than 1 million sold zdnet.com
  2. A platinum debut shows iTunes has hit potential baltimoresun.com
  3. An Economist's Guide to Digital Music epub.ub.uni-muenchen.de