The encyclopedia · Finance & Accounting · Strategic decision · 2012

The ECB's 'whatever it takes' pledge ended the euro crisis without spending a euro

In 2012 the ECB created an unlimited conditional bond-buying facility; announcing it, never using it, crushed the eurozone's panic spreads

European Central Bank

the move

In mid-2012 euro-area bond spreads on Spain and Italy blew out as investors priced in a possible breakup of the single currency. A government caught in that spiral faced borrowing costs driven by fear rather than by fundamentals.

The obvious fixes — the ECB printing money to buy bonds, or a bailout — were politically blocked or seen as too costly. Instead, on 6 September 2012 the ECB formalised Outright Monetary Transactions, an unlimited facility to buy short-dated sovereign bonds of any country that accepted a strict EFSF/ESM programme.

The design made the promise both credible and conditional, so it worked as insurance rather than as spending. The facility was never used; the announcement alone collapsed spreads, which is why the ECB was credited with saving the euro without spending a euro under OMT's name.

why it works

Fear, not debt, drove the spreads; a credible backstop broke a self-fulfilling panic
Conditionality tied to an EFSF/ESM programme made the promise acceptable to creditor countries
Unlimited size and 'whatever it takes' made the commitment credible enough that markets stopped testing it
Because it was never activated, the facility cost nothing and set a template for later ECB backstops

the payoffA credible, endless backstop ends a panic without being usedinspired

what transfers

A panic driven by self-fulfilling fear can be stopped by a credible, conditional and unlimited guarantee — and by never having to spend the money

what came after

OMT was never activated. Spanish and Italian spreads fell sharply after the 2012 announcement and the euro survived. Germany's Constitutional Court challenged the programme; in 2015 the European Court of Justice ruled it lawful within the ECB's mandate. The design — a large, conditional, unspent backstop — became the template for the ECB's later pandemic purchase programme and for the idea that a credible commitment can substitute for money. Critics argue it relieved pressure on governments to reform and blurred the line between monetary and fiscal policy.

references

spotted an error? The archive wants to know.

same kind of clever

2016–2017 · Finance & Accounting