#9 1967 · Berkshire Hathaway · Insurance
Buffett bought insurers for the money that sits between premium and claim
the problem
Premiums lay idle until claims came due
background
Berkshire Hathaway in the mid-1960s was a dying New England textile mill; Buffett had taken it over as a value bet, but manufacturing capital was structurally trapped — every dollar reinvested in looms competed against cheaper Southern and overseas mills for a shrinking margin. The obvious moves were to run the mills harder or liquidate; neither turned the company into a compounding machine.
In 1967 Buffett instead used Berkshire's cash to buy National Indemnity, a small Omaha insurer, for $8.6 million. Insurers already sat on float — premiums collected before claims are paid — but most of the industry invested it conservatively in bonds and treated underwriting, not the float itself, as the business. Buffett saw National Indemnity's investment portfolio as something he could redirect toward better returns, and ran the float aggressively rather than conservatively.
the move
Buffett bought insurers explicitly for float — premiums held before claims — describing it as money held but not owned, investable in the meantime.
the payoff
Float grew from tens of millions to well over $100B and financed much of Berkshire's compounding.
what came after
Berkshire's insurance float grew from $39 million in 1970 to $114.5 billion by the end of 2017, and in his 2004 shareholder letter Buffett wrote that "had we not made this acquisition, Berkshire would be lucky to be worth half of what it is today." Fairfax Financial, Markel and Exor later built similar insurer-as-investment-vehicle structures.
filed under
references
- [1]Warren Buffett and the Insurance Business: A 52-Year Love StoryYahoo Finance, 2019finance.yahoo.com
- [2]Berkshire Hathaway Chairman Warren Buffett on Insurance Economics and 2004 ResultsInsurance Journal, 2005insurancejournal.com